phd literature review help
help me with my homework proxy
online help for writing research papers
writing windows services in vb
write my essay 4 me
top resume service online
help on writing scholarship essays
1984 george orwell help
order conspectus paper
cv writing service reviews uk
freelance writers online
custom paper napkins toronto
professional personal essay writers
help with writing a sonnet poem
custom essay papers 7
how to write a windows service in c 2008
essay good bad customer service
essay writing service legit
help with an essay
professional resume writers groupon
writers freelance contract
new zealand essay writing service
professional assignment writers australia
help with english homework ks3
what is the best college essay editing service
digest writing services london
abstract helpers
report writer cover letter
dissertation help new york
business finance homework help
custom made personal statement
buy a condensation
homework help textbook solutions
what should i write my essay about
help essays
cv writing services reviews uk
top 10 dissertation writers
ap english literature essay help
death penalty research paper help
my community service essay
do my assignment cheap
professional cv services
top recommendation letter writing services online
buy papers online
does homework help high school students
cover letter for internship help
physics homework helper
need synopsis help
i don39t want to do my homework help
customized paper bags uk
help me write an essay free
accounting homework services
admission essay help
customer service term paper topics
help with research paper thesis statement
abridgment help san diego
how to write my dissertation proposal
help with writing report cards
research paper on customer relationship management .pdf
top 10 resume writing services
jurisprudence essay help
buy cheap toilet paper
best online condensation writing services
custom essay writing services cheap
buy an essay in the uk
help writing a precis for a precis
homework help for 7th grade math
best professional abstract writing services
homework help computer science
sat essay help
places to buy resume paper
speech helpers
need help writing my paper
paper mario helpers
best resume writers in atlanta
best custom college papers
video games help improve critical thinking
resume and cover letter writing services
phd thesis help india
how does creative writing help kids
buy your own iron on paper
custom writer39s reference
i didn39t do my homework help
case study dissociative identity disorder
holt middle school math course 1 homework help
cheap papers for printer
certified federal resume writing service
conspectus help chicago
paperback writer chords beatles
annotated bibliography helper
cheap paperback books online
examples of customer service resume titles
buy paper bags online ireland
curriculum vitae professional service uk
management accounting homework help
create custom css tumblr
purchase a conspectus
custom made essays free
cv writing services in kenya
executive resume writing service minneapolis
christian book review of the help
business plan writer raleigh nc
essay about help poor people
resume writing services ottawa ontario
research paper order online
free help with writing papers
things to research when buying a house
purchase essay papers
custom writing paper template
order custom rolling papers
freelance online writer resume
free resume writer wizard
application letter for janitorial services
birth order essay outline
houston area resume writing service
homework helpers chemistry review
custom paper napkins
professional cv writing service reviews
reading helps critical thinking
argumentative essay about is homework helpful or harmful
professional resume writing service singapore
application letter for customer service agent
free help with cv writing
the help film review independent
custom research north america
buy college books online india
college essay service trip
buy authentic college football jerseys
essay writers free
help with a brief
help with assignments online
hiring a grant writer
how to get paid to write movie reviews
resume writing services columbia sc
help assignment locus
get paid to write reviews in india
discursive essay help
freelance writers paid
cv cover letter service
how much does a music ghostwriter make
college accounting homework help
personal statement community service example
best outline writing services in atlanta ga
count desk essay neatness writer
research papers customer retention strategies
medical cv writing service uk
research before buying a car
buy essay online for cheap
ghostwriting services australia
make business budget plan
buy your research paper
customwritings.com customer reviews
need help making a compendium
homework help chemical equations
custom essay meister coupon
write my essay please
need help writing a persuasive essay
get homework done for free
buy a cv
buy a financial planning business
a case study on bipolar disorder
i need free math homework help
medical school personal statement service
how to write a essay to get into college
help with abridgments
cheap private universities
buy already written essays
resume services in miami fl
inexpensive resume writing services
executive digest writers nyc
graduate essay service
research proposal writing service
certified resume writers toronto
help with writing digest
best resume writers in uk
art homework help
criterion online essay evaluation services
sample cover letter for web content writer
buying dissertations
order recommendation letter paper
homework help hotline atlanta
cv writers in leicester
write my critical thinking
where to buy nice paper for resume
resume writing services oklahoma city ok
cv writing help london
customer service presentation powerpoint
how does critical thinking help a student
professional condensation services
essays on helping the community
online homework helper free
professional cv services limerick
best article writing services
write my high school admissions essay
famous essay writers
writing paper with borders printable
homework help riverside ca
help with brief
free online help with english homework
custom essay help

Federal Judge: Obamacare Ain’t Legal

A federal judge ruled today the entire health care reform legislation is unconstitutional.

Here’s one of the most revealing sections of his ruling, which you can read here:

“This Act has been analogized to a finely crafted watch, and that seems to fit. It has approximately 450 separate pieces, but one essential piece (the individual mandate) is defective and must be removed. It cannot function as originally designed. There are simply too many moving parts in the Act and too many provisions dependent (directly and indirectly) on the individual mandate and other health insurance provisions — which, as noted, were the chief engines that drove the entire legislative effort — for me to try and dissect out the proper from the improper, and the able-to-stand-alone from the unable-to-stand-alone.

“Such a quasi-legislative undertaking would be particularly inappropriate in light of the fact that any statute that might conceivably be left over after this analysis is complete would plainly not serve Congress’ main purpose and primary objective in passing the Act. The statute is, after all, called “The Patient Protection and Affordable are Act,” not “The Abstinence Education and Bone Marrow Density Testing Act.” The Act, like a defectively designed watch, needs to be redesigned and reconstructed by the watchmaker.”

Update: For those keeping score, the health care reform law has now collected 2 rulings upholding it and 2 against it. The 2 for it come from Democratic-appointed judges; the 2 against come from Republican appointees.

The 2 rulings against the law open an interesting philosophical rift. Today’s ruling says the law’s mandate that generally everyone has to buy insurance – supposedly spreading the risk and money stream around evenly – is unconstitutional. It also says that so-called individual mandate is so interwoven into the fabric of the law that Congress has no choice but to scrap the whole thing and start over.

The other Republican judge who ruled against the law didn’t go that far. He said the individual mandate wasn’t constitutional, but he thinks the law can still stand up without that provision.

Meanwhile, here’s another excerpt from today’s ruling which gives a quasi Tea Party shout-out:

“It is difficult to imagine that a nation which began, at least in part, as the result of opposition to a British mandate giving the East India Company a monopoly and imposing a nominal tax on all tea sold in America, would have set out to create a government with the power to force people to buy tea in the first place. If Congress can penalize a passive individual for failing to engage in commerce, the enumeration of powers in the Constitution would have been in vain, for it would be “difficult to perceive any limitation on federal power”, and we would have a Constitution in name only. Surely this is not what the Founding Fathers could have intended.”

Dansette

google